Novena
  • About
  • Authors
    • Cameron Doody
    • Mada Jurado
    • Matt Kappadakunnel
    • Angele Bucyte
    • Pressenza International Press Agency
    • George Karpouzas
    • Daniele Palmer
    • Danail Hristov
    • Katakombablog
  • Countries
    • Albania
    • Austria
    • Belarus
    • Belgium
    • Bosnia-Herzegovina
    • Brussels
    • Bulgaria
    • Croatia
    • Czech Republic
    • Denmark
    • Estonia
    • Europe
    • Finland
    • France
    • Geneva
    • Georgia
    • Germany
    • Greece
    • Hungary
    • Iceland
    • Ireland
    • Italy
    • Kosovo
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Luxembourg
    • Malta
    • Moldova
    • Montenegro
    • Netherlands
    • Norway
    • Order of Malta
    • Poland
    • Portugal
    • Romania
    • Russia
    • Serbia
    • Slovakia
    • Slovenia
    • Spain
    • Sweden
    • Switzerland
    • Turkey
    • Ukraine
    • US
    • Vatican
    • World
  • In-depth
    • About Novena
    • Agencies
    • Analysis
    • Catholic Twitter
    • Editorial
    • Full text
    • Novena book review
    • Novena exclusive
    • Novena guest article
    • Novena interview
    • Novena investigates
    • Novena most-read
    • Novena opinion
    • Novena profile
    • Novena readers respond
    • Press releases
    • Pressenza
    • Special to Novena
    • Viewpoints
  • Archives
    • November 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • July 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    • September 2019
    • August 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS

Catholic Twitter piles on traditionalist Cardinal Burke for protesting he’s no “enemy” of Pope Francis

By Novena November 10, 2019
Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Catholic Twitter has piled on traditionalist Cardinal Raymond Burke for protesting that he’s not an “enemy” of Pope Francis.

Driving the news

The Dubia-emitting, Amazon Synod-criticising cardinal protested to conservative journalist Ross Douthat in the New York Times that “now I find myself in a situation where I’m called the enemy of the pope, which I am not”.

“I haven’t changed. I’m still teaching the same things I always taught and they’re not my ideas”, Burke complained.

“But now suddenly this is perceived as being contrary to the Roman pontiff. And I think here what’s entered in is a very political view of the papacy, where the pope is some kind of absolute monarch who can do whatever he wants.

“That has never been the case in the church. The pope is not a revolutionary, elected to change the church’s teaching. And a lot of the secular view is people looking at the church, but not understanding her profound reality”, Burke said.

Go deeper

Burke affirmed that while the Amazon Synod final document “is less explicit in the embrace of pantheism, it does not repudiate the statements in the working document which constitute an apostasy from the Catholic faith”.

“The working document doesn’t have doctrinal value. But what if the pope were to put his stamp on that document?”, the cardinal asked.

“People say if you don’t accept that, you’ll be in schism – and I maintain that I would not be in schism because the document contains elements that defect from the apostolic tradition.

“So my point would be the document is schismatic. I’m not”.

Asked whether he was, with these sentiments, “effectively implying that the pope would be leading a schism” if he accepted the Amazon Synod final document, Burke replied simply: “Yes”.

But while he laid that responsibility for potential division in the Church squarely at the feet of Pope Francis, Burke said he personally would never take part in that kind of rupture.

“Schism, that can never be the will of Christ. Christ can never will a division in his body”, Burke explained.

“People come to me and say, look, cardinal, it’s time, we have to go into schism. And I say no, it’s not possible. Our Lord can’t want that, and I’m not going to be part of any schism”.

On the Amazon Synod, too, Burke was asked for his opinion of the indigenous fertility Mother Earth statuettes that graced some of the Amazon Synod proceedings.

Those statuettes were displayed in a Roman church during the Synod until a young Austrian, Alexander Tschugguel, stole them and dumped them in the Tiber river.

“The statue in question is an idol”, Burke affirmed, despite Vatican claims that it was a native depiction of Our Lady of the Amazon.

But the cardinal affirmed he had no prior knowledge that Tschugguel was going to steal and profane the statuettes.

“While I know quite well and regard highly Alexander Tschugguel, especially for his courageous and tireless work in defending the inviolability of innocent human life and the integrity of the family, I had nothing to do with his removal of the pagan idols from the Church of Santa Maria in Traspontina and his throwing them into the Tiber”, Burke protested.

“At the same time, knowing his deep Catholic faith, I can understand why he found it intolerable that pagan idols be displayed in a Catholic church.

“It reminds me of similar situations in Old Testament times, for example, the case of the Maccabee brothers, and the case of so many confessors and martyrs, who would not tolerate that the Catholic faith be denied through the worship of pagan idols.

“Having listened to Alexander’s statement regarding his actions, I can only express my respect for him and my gratitude for his courageous witness to the faith”, Burke said.

Why it matters

For his doublespeak on his opposition to the Pope, his hypocrisy on schism and his duplicity over the theft of the ‘Pachamama’ statues, Burke quickly became the object of the criticism of Catholic commentators on Twitter.

Joseph the Benedictine summed up Burke’s interview thus:

“To put it simply: I’m not [the Pope’s] enemy, I just like to publicly shame him by declaring him wrong and by turning people against him. You know how the saying goes: ‘With friends like this….?'”

“Burke is one sly prelate. On the surface he says his is not the Pope’s enemy, that he is not in favor of schism, but goes on to allege that the Pope is in error”, Joseph the Benedictine observed.

“He chooses his words carefully: he says he was unaware of the theft and drowning of the ‘idols’ (not ‘statues’) but ‘I know quite well and regard highly Alexander Tschugguel’, so what he did was okay? Burke’s opposition to the Pope is obvious”.

Calling Burke’s overall position “incoherent nonsense” and criticising his “cognitive dissonance” in recoginising but not respecting Pope Francis, Twitter user Mike Lewis called the cardinal’s interview a “long-winded exercise in excuse-making”.

“But, I will grant him this”, Lewis added ironically.

“[Burke] does publicly affirm that he believes Francis is pope. He also states that he will continue to defy him”.

Twitter user Brian Killian said that Burke and his traditionalist co-conspirators – by affirming Francis is pope but then doing their best to undermine his papacy – “would rather affirm the ecclesiastical version of a ‘square circle’ than believe that they could ever be the ones inciting schism or causing confusion”.

Twitter user Tony Annett accepted Burke’s protests that he is not the enemy of the Pope, but then criticised the cardinal for continuing to “associate” with people who do have it in for Francis, such as “extremists” like Taylor Marshall, Michael Voris of the website Church Militant and John-Henry Westen of LifeSite News.

Other Twitter users like Andrea Manea blasted the New York Times for printing “such a dishonest piece against the Holy Father”.

“No morals, no respect for truth, but actively helping the most evil and corrupt players”, Manea denounced.

“Oh. Ross Douthat”, Twitter user William D. Lindsey continued in the anti-New York Times line.

“Well, then — if Cardinal Burke says he’s a Francis fanboy and Douthat reports that to us, this must all be true. About like Stephen Miller or Donald Trump saying he’s not a white supremacist”.

Twitter user Rachel Dobbs, for her part, criticised Burke for causing “more division and dissension within the church” with his interview.

“[Burke] should just get out if he won’t be obedient. He’s a cardinal, he’s supposed to be obedient to the Pope”, Dobbs said.

“For someone who prides himself on tradition and respect, he has a glaring absence of both to the present pope and his policies”, Twitter user Leo Armbrust wryly observed, for his part, of Burke’s interview.

Twitter user Mike recalled that Burke’s 2016 dubia to the Pope “was an effort to embarrass Francis, to showboat”.

“It was done in bad faith, which is why Francis never answered it and shouldn’t answer it. Burke speaks out of both sides of his mouth”, Mike denounced.

Burke is just “like the mullahs”, decried for her part Twitter user Random Woman.

“It’s my way or the highway. Not the message modern Catholicism needs to project. I lived in St Louis when [Burke] was there. He was very unpopular”, Random Woman said.

“So disappointing”, Twitter user Michael Bowen simply said, criticising Burke’s admission that he is still teaching “the same things I always taught”.

“Ideas, concepts, new ways, alternatives all together give renewal – this Pope is a revolutionary who understands a new reality is needed to get the church out of the quicksand of irrelevance. Let’s move on!”, Bowen tweeted.

Next on Novena:

Ultraconservative Cardinal Burke blasts populist Steve Bannon, ‘fake news’ LifeSite

Six times ultraconservative Cardinal Sarah opposed Pope Francis

"conservatives" and "liberals"opposition to pope francis
Avatar
Author Novena

Related Posts

Pope repeats call for end to death penalty: “Not even a murderer loses his personal dignity – God Himself guarantees it”

November 30, 2020

Pope appeals to warmongers in Ethiopia: “Stop the violence, protect all lives and restore peace”

November 28, 2020

Pope pleads: “We all need to do a lot more for the dignity of each woman”

November 25, 2020

Pope, Grand Imam of Al-Azhar recommit to human fraternity as solution to religious extremism

November 22, 2020

Pope condemns fundamentalist intolerance, urges respect, love and care for human dignity

November 18, 2020

On Environment Conflict Day, Pope denounces impact of war on Common Home

November 6, 2020
  • Headlines
    • The end of an era: A farewell from Novena November 30, 2020
    • Pope repeats call for end to death penalty: “Not even a murderer loses his personal dignity – God Himself guarantees it” November 30, 2020
    • Francis alerts: “Violence will never cease until all people reach a deeper awareness that they are brothers and sisters” November 30, 2020
    • Permanent deacon and wife take over day-to-day leadership of Portuguese parish November 30, 2020
    • Spanish Church groups denounce “systematic violation of human rights” of migrants on southern European border November 30, 2020
    • Aid to the Church in Need denounces Christians the most persecuted religious group in the world November 30, 2020
    • “Leave no-one behind! COVID-19 and climate change merit equal engagement”, stress Jesuits in Europe and Africa November 30, 2020
    • Gay man rejected by Jesuits: “The God who loves me is not the sole property of a Church that rejects LGBTQ people” November 29, 2020
    • Pope urges new cardinals to “watchfulness of prayer and charity” to escape “slumber of mediocrity and indifference” November 29, 2020
    • Opinion: “Sexual abuse has fatally undermined the Catholic Church’s claim to represent a moral authority” November 29, 2020
    • Pope warns new red hats: “The scarlet of a cardinal’s robes can, for a worldly spirit, become the colour of a secular ’eminence'” November 28, 2020
    • Pope appeals to warmongers in Ethiopia: “Stop the violence, protect all lives and restore peace” November 28, 2020
    • Vatican diplomat deplores “sad” governmental, societal rejection of in-demand migrant workers November 28, 2020
    • With new picks for red hats, Francis working to correct Eurocentric bias in College of Cardinals November 28, 2020
    • To combat religiously motivated violence, invest in interfaith dialogue, research suggests November 27, 2020
    • Cardinal Czerny denounces migrants, refugees being “deliberately forgotten” by governments during COVID November 27, 2020
    • Cardinal Hollerich warns: “The EU will lose its soul in the Mediterranean if it does not save refugees from drowning” November 27, 2020
    • Canon lawyer accuses Cardinal Woelki of “unprecedented brazenness” for suppressing Cologne archdiocesan abuse cover-up report November 27, 2020
    • Cardinal-designate Cornelius Sim: “Jesus’ way of acting is from person to person, being small with the little ones” November 27, 2020
    • Pope calls on Christians to “engage with the world with strength and creativity” to build “a new, inclusive economy and a politics of love” November 27, 2020
    • Jesuit expert in marketing hits out at “voracious consumerism” of ‘Black Friday’ November 27, 2020
    • Did the Pope just criticise the German ‘synodal path’ Church reform process? Key lay body says ‘no’ November 26, 2020
    • Pope talks social, environmental justice with delegation from Fairtrade International November 26, 2020
    • Francis thanks young people in Italy for ‘Advent Green Dream’ radio program November 26, 2020
    • Congolese cardinal urges Swiss to vote ‘yes’ on Corporate Responsibility Initiative: “Companies that pollute or exploit must be held accountable” November 26, 2020
    • Spanish cardinals condemn gender-based violence: “Jesus always stood for the equal dignity of men and women” November 26, 2020
    • Pope says firm ‘no’ to party politics in Church: “We should not be sectarian, one against the other” November 26, 2020
    • Swedish cardinal puts COVID Mass restrictions in perspective: “There are greater sufferings in the world” November 26, 2020
    • Catholic women clap back at Pope for calling their struggle for ordination “clericalist”, “disrespectful” November 25, 2020
    • Vatican stresses interreligious dialogue as only path to peace, freedom November 25, 2020
    • China says Pope’s claim of “persecuted” Uyghurs “absolutely groundless” November 25, 2020
    • New book lifts lid on “shocking” sexual and spiritual abuse of women in Church November 25, 2020
    • Pope pleads: “We all need to do a lot more for the dignity of each woman” November 25, 2020
    • Spanish Catholic NGO decries “widespread apathy” in face of fact 30% of world’s women and girls live in fear of violence November 25, 2020
    • German abbess prosecuted for sheltering asylum seekers wins Göttingen Peace Prize November 25, 2020
    • Vatican webinar condemns racism as “blasphemy against the Creator”, “sin against the message of Christ” November 24, 2020
  • In the news
    "conservatives" and "liberals" abuse abuse of power accountability bishops celibacy christian identity church and state clericalism common home coronavirus ecology economy environment eu europe faith gender equality health healthcare inclusion integral human development laypeople lgbt+ rights medicine migrants nationalism peace politics poor prayer priesthood racism reform refugees religious life secularisation sex abuse social justice society solidarity spirituality synodality theology women in the church
  • More news by country
  • More news by date
  • Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
    To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • About

    Novena is an independent, lay-run, self-financed news website that offers accurate, credible and insightful coverage of issues that affect Europeans at the intersection of religion, politics, society and culture.

    Read More
  • Most-read
    • No longer sin? Archbishop of Paris backs withdrawal method over pill, condoms
    • The Napa Institute is passing off poisonous right-wing vinegar as gospel wine
    • Vatican official: Coronavirus "not God's punishment, but our own self-punishment"
  • Search
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • About
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

Novena

Top
  • About
  • Authors
    • Cameron Doody
    • Mada Jurado
    • Matt Kappadakunnel
    • Angele Bucyte
    • Pressenza International Press Agency
    • George Karpouzas
    • Daniele Palmer
    • Danail Hristov
    • Katakombablog
  • Countries
    • Albania
    • Austria
    • Belarus
    • Belgium
    • Bosnia-Herzegovina
    • Brussels
    • Bulgaria
    • Croatia
    • Czech Republic
    • Denmark
    • Estonia
    • Europe
    • Finland
    • France
    • Geneva
    • Georgia
    • Germany
    • Greece
    • Hungary
    • Iceland
    • Ireland
    • Italy
    • Kosovo
    • Latvia
    • Lithuania
    • Luxembourg
    • Malta
    • Moldova
    • Montenegro
    • Netherlands
    • Norway
    • Order of Malta
    • Poland
    • Portugal
    • Romania
    • Russia
    • Serbia
    • Slovakia
    • Slovenia
    • Spain
    • Sweden
    • Switzerland
    • Turkey
    • Ukraine
    • US
    • Vatican
    • World
  • In-depth
    • About Novena
    • Agencies
    • Analysis
    • Catholic Twitter
    • Editorial
    • Full text
    • Novena book review
    • Novena exclusive
    • Novena guest article
    • Novena interview
    • Novena investigates
    • Novena most-read
    • Novena opinion
    • Novena profile
    • Novena readers respond
    • Press releases
    • Special to Novena
    • Viewpoints
  • Archives
    • November 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • July 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    • September 2019
    • August 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
  • Contact
  • Social networks
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • RSS
    • Scribd
    • Email

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.