(November 10, 2020)

Millions of Americans chanted, “Defund the Police” following the murders of Breonna Taylor and George Floyd, among many others.

I believe we in the US Catholic Church can similarly chant, “Defund the Bishops.”

Just as the first statement has a more in-depth connotation than meets the eye, the same goes for the second statement.

The release of the McCarrick Report supports that bishops wield excessive power and may use it for self-interest as opposed to the good of the Church.

Therefore, the need to defund the bishops is not solely financial, but to ensure there are rightful checks and balances to prevent an egregious use of power for personal gain.

For far too long, bishops have acted like temporal lords in their respective dioceses without proper safeguards to temper this “lordship.”

The following activities of bishops (not exhaustive in nature) warrant the removal of access to Church funds and the need for appropriate checks and balances:

  • Engaging in or covering up a scandal, whether or not it is sexual in nature
  • Engaging in partisan politics to the extent of representing that such and such candidate/position adheres to Church teaching, and the opposite is a sin
  • Promoting abuse (whether spiritual or sexual), clericalism and toxic masculinity

Below are examples of those following points (again not exhaustive in nature):

Engaging in or covering up a scandal, whether or not if it is sexual in nature:

Engaging in partisan politics to the extent representing that such and such candidate/position adheres to Church teaching, and the opposite is a sin:

Promoting abuse (whether spiritual or sexual), clericalism and toxic masculinity:

For the aforementioned bishops who are still active, they have a duty to step down and accept judgment.

If they are unwilling to do this, I urge the faithful to not underestimate the power of their financial contributions to their respective dioceses and withhold these funds until these bishops account for their actions and receive their due punishment. 

Moreover, I urge that new canonical checks and balances be established to prevent a bishop’s egregious use of power for self-interest as well as to continue and cover up for abuse.

The Church has spent too much time and money defending the bishops.  Now the Church must defund the guilty bishops. 

More insight by Novena US contributor Matt Kappadakunnel:

Black Lives are being aborted, and not just in the womb. How long will the US Bishops remain complicit?

Racism, misogyny and anti-papism: this is the “Catholic” Crisis

By naming Wilton Gregory a cardinal, the Pope is sending a powerful message that Black Lives Matter

Jesus wouldn’t make fun of a person’s name… and neither should we


If you enjoyed this article, why not show us your support?
Help build a broad Catholic Church! Contribute to Novena

Avatar
Author

Matt Kappadakunnel has a background in investment management and investment banking. Additionally, Matt spent multiple years studying to be a Catholic priest. He is a graduate of Creighton University and is a CFA Charterholder. Matt lives in Los Angeles with his wife and toddler, and they are expecting a newborn in November.